According to the Terms of Use of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation's Web site [1] concerning "Your Links to Our Site" (point #11) :
You are not permitted to link or shortcut to our Site from your Web site, blog or similar application, without obtaining prior written permission from us. (source: http://www.gatesfoundation.org/about/Pages/terms-of-use.aspx, link created)
This has been published on Identi.ca on May 30th (http://identi.ca/notice/34172392), but without details and Daniel Glazman wrote about it, Bill Gates and the Web. This point #11 means at least 10 issues in details:
- what about the Web search engines: Bing, Yahoo! or Google have a permission?
- a RSS feed is an hypertext link: so, no RSS?
- in a newsletter or email, writing the adress means creating a link...
- Twitter and Facebook make link: do they have a permission?
- many email signature have a web site URL and a link is made... change the signature of all the employees?
- in any modern word processor, spreadsheet or presentation programm, a written URL becomes a link: a student, a teacher, a journalist using them needs to ask before quoting the URL...
- instant messaging tools (like Windows Live) make automatically a link: ask for the permission before quoting the site...
- on forum and web pages comments, impossible to write the Web site without permission?
- a bookmark is a link stored in a file: do not save Web sites in bookmarks without asking permission?
- TinyURL are not allowed without permission...
And two more things: writing the URL but linking to another Web site is forbidden? (or linking to a 404 error page?); and what about the linkification Firefox add-on?
A web link is open, like HTML is an open format: here is what Sir Tim Berners Lee wrote about Links and Law: Myths , http://www.w3.org/DesignIssues/LinkMyths.html
PS: on the opposite site, the Gates Notes Web site does not have that point: in its Terms of Use page: http://www.thegatesnotes.com/Terms-Of-Use/.
2 réactions
1 De hawkeyeaz1 - 07/06/2010, 21:59
Did you get permission to post that URL?
2 De Thierry Stoehr - 08/06/2010, 22:55
Oups I made a link on the URL! Not even necessary with linkification add-on wich "converts text links into genuine, clickable links.", addons.mozilla.org/en-US/...